How ‘1923’ Captures the Vanishing West—And Why Harrison Ford Is All In

1923, the latest installment in Taylor Sheridan’s Yellowstone universe, stands out as a unique and modern take on the classic Western genre. Unlike traditional Westerns, which have often romanticized a bygone era of the American frontier, 1923 is acutely aware of how the West transformed into myth and history. This self-awareness, combined with a deep examination of the tension between preservation and progress, is what makes 1923 truly remarkable—and what Harrison Ford, one of the series’ stars, calls its greatest strength.

A Throwback to Classic Westerns, but with a Twist

Westerns have been experiencing something of a resurgence in recent years, thanks in large part to the success of Sheridan’s Yellowstone franchise. But what sets 1923 apart is its setting in a transitional period, decades after the Wild West has faded. Ford, who grew up during the Western genre’s heyday, is passionate about reviving the feel of old-school, physical storytelling. Speaking at the Season 2 premiere, Ford expressed his appreciation for the visceral, natural world depicted in 1923. He emphasized the importance of using “old-time storytelling” that focuses on the environment and characters, rather than relying on CGI effects. His commitment to this method mirrors the show’s dedication to showcasing the raw beauty of the American landscape, from the Montana plains to its rugged mountains.

In a rapidly modernizing world, the natural beauty and untamed spirit of the land that the Duttons fought to preserve is as much a character in the story as the people themselves. Ford’s character, Jacob Dutton, exemplifies the deep connection to the land, fighting to protect the legacy of the Yellowstone ranch as external forces of industrialization and capitalism threaten their way of life. The antagonist of the series, Donald Whitfield (played by Timothy Dalton), serves as a symbol of modernity itself—personifying the capitalist greed that conflicts with the preservation of tradition.

Idealistic Yet Cynical: The Dual Nature of 1923

What makes 1923 particularly powerful is its ability to balance both idealism and cynicism regarding the West. While the series showcases the Duttons’ steadfast adherence to their values, it also acknowledges the cultural erasure and violence that accompanied the expansion of the American frontier. The portrayal of Native American suffering, particularly through the character of Teonna Rainwater (played by Aminah Nieves), serves as a sobering reminder that the injustices of colonization and cultural genocide didn’t end with the conquest of the West—they continued well into the 20th century.

This nuanced approach allows 1923 to deconstruct the Western mythos while still embracing its more romanticized elements. The show doesn’t shy away from depicting the harsh realities of the American frontier, yet it never dismisses the love many hold for the idea of the Wild West. It is, in essence, an honest portrayal of the period—one that acknowledges both the beauty and the brutality that shaped it.

A World in Transition

Unlike 1883, which focused on the hardships of migration across the plains, 1923 explores the Duttons’ struggle to adapt to an increasingly urbanized and industrialized world. Moments like Cara Dutton (Helen Mirren) being puzzled by the use of a telephone serve as subtle but poignant reminders of the alienation felt by those who once thrived in a simpler, more self-sufficient time. This disorientation reflects a broader societal shift that the Duttons—and by extension, the show itself—are struggling to navigate. 1923 brings to light the clash between the freedom of the past and the constraints of the present, emphasizing that the Duttons’ quest for independence is as much about preserving their cultural identity as it is about holding onto the land.

A Love Story and a Western

One of 1923‘s standout elements is its ability to blend multiple genres while staying true to its Western roots. While the series is first and foremost a Western, it also incorporates elements of romance. The storyline of Spencer Dutton (Brandon Sklenar) and Alexandra (Julia Schlaepfer), who battle against all odds to return to Montana from British East Africa, brings an unexpected layer to the narrative. This subplot, set in a vastly different environment, further highlights the changing world of the Duttons and underscores the timeless nature of love, even amidst a backdrop of historical upheaval.

By intertwining these various subgenres, 1923 opens itself up to new audiences who might not typically gravitate toward Westerns. Yet, even with these additions, the series remains grounded in its core identity, capturing the essence of what made the West so mythic while acknowledging the complexities of the world that followed.

Revitalizing the Western Genre

Ultimately, 1923 serves as a revitalization of the Western genre, but with a modern perspective. It successfully combines both the old-fashioned appeal of the Western and a critical examination of the past, making it relevant to today’s audiences. As Ford and his fellow cast members navigate the evolving world of the Duttons, the show asks important questions about cultural identity, the preservation of history, and the impact of progress on the American landscape.

In this way, 1923 honors the tradition of the Western while breathing new life into it, ensuring that the genre remains not only a part of Hollywood’s past but a relevant and evolving force in its future. Ford’s praise for the show’s “old-time storytelling” is well-deserved—1923 is both a love letter to the past and a powerful meditation on the ever-changing American frontier.