Stallone Remembers Carl Weathers’ Rocky Audition—And The Surprising Moment That Led to His Iconic Role

Following the passing of Carl Weathers on February 1, 2024, at the age of 76, tributes from co-stars and collaborators have poured in, with Sylvester Stallone offering a heartfelt reflection on their time together during the making of the Rocky series. Weathers, who famously portrayed Apollo Creed, Rocky Balboa’s fierce rival and eventual friend, left an indelible mark on the iconic film franchise. In a February 2024 appearance on The Tonight Show, Stallone shared the memorable story of Weathers’ audition for the role of Apollo, underscoring the actor’s undeniable talent, presence, and physicality.

Stallone’s Account of Weathers’ Audition

Stallone’s recollection of Weathers’ audition provides a behind-the-scenes glimpse into the casting process for the groundbreaking 1976 film. According to Stallone, Weathers arrived in a “bad mood,” which, to Stallone, was the perfect fit for Apollo Creed’s character. The audition, which took place when Weathers was still playing for the Oakland Raiders, included a physical test that left a lasting impression on Stallone. Weathers took off his shirt to showcase his impressive physique, which Stallone humorously compared to his own, saying, “I looked like Pooh Bear next to him, and he looked like Adonis.”

The physicality of the audition didn’t stop there. As Stallone recounted, Weathers landed “about three shots off my forehead,” a demonstration of his athleticism and skill that convinced Stallone immediately. “Hired! He had it all,” Stallone recalled exclaiming after the impressive demonstration. He highlighted that Apollo’s role required a unique combination of “incredible athleticism, brains, spirit, talent, and speed,” all of which Weathers embodied effortlessly.

Stallone’s tribute to his late co-star also included emotional reflections on their deep professional and personal connection. He expressed his shock at Weathers’ passing, emphasizing the profound bond they shared both in and out of the ring. Stallone even shared behind-the-scenes footage of their rehearsal for the final fight scene in Rocky, which further showcased the physicality and chemistry that defined their dynamic.

Weathers’ Version of the Audition

While Stallone’s account focused on the physical component of the audition, Weathers himself shared a different version of the event in a 2015 interview with The Hollywood Reporter. Weathers recalled that, during the audition, there was no one else to read with, and he was asked to read with Stallone, the writer and star. He felt that the scene didn’t quite hit the mark, leading him to blurt out, “I could do a lot better if you got me a real actor to work with.” This bold remark, which was aimed at Stallone, whom Weathers did not initially recognize as the star, is believed to have played a pivotal role in securing the role of Apollo.

The difference between Stallone’s focus on the physicality of the audition and Weathers’ emphasis on the verbal interaction could reflect the differing ways both men viewed the process. Stallone’s perspective, as both the writer and star of Rocky, likely emphasized the physicality crucial to portraying a boxer, while Weathers, looking back years later, recalled the verbal exchange that had become a defining moment in his audition story.

The Physical Component: A Deeper Look

The physicality that Stallone describes in Weathers’ audition raises interesting questions about traditional audition practices, especially for a film set in the world of sports. Given Weathers’ background as a former NFL linebacker, his athleticism would have been a key asset in the role. It’s plausible that the audition included a physical screen test or improv, simulating the kind of confrontation seen in the film’s fight scenes. The fact that Stallone felt “in trouble” next to Weathers physically highlights the chemistry test that was likely part of the casting process.

The physical demonstration of strength and skill during the audition was not just about showing off muscle, but about proving the character’s credibility as a boxer. Apollo Creed had to be a formidable opponent for Rocky, both in terms of physical prowess and charisma. Weathers’ impressive build and the way he owned the physical space during the audition undoubtedly solidified his place as Apollo.

The Legacy of Carl Weathers in Rocky and Beyond

The story of Weathers’ audition for Rocky adds another layer to his lasting impact on the franchise. From his fierce rivalry with Rocky to his evolution into a close ally, Apollo Creed’s journey was one of the most compelling arcs in cinematic history. Stallone’s tribute underscores the immense contribution Weathers made to the Rocky series, acknowledging that without him, the films wouldn’t have been the same. “I couldn’t have done it without him,” Stallone said, highlighting the essential role Weathers played in making Rocky a true classic.

Weathers’ portrayal of Apollo Creed went beyond just the role of a rival. Over the course of the first four Rocky films, Apollo became an iconic character whose influence reached far beyond the boxing ring. Their on-screen chemistry helped elevate the franchise, creating one of Hollywood’s most beloved pairings.

Conclusion: A Tribute to a Legendary Partnership

Carl Weathers’ passing has left a void in the hearts of fans and co-stars alike. Through his powerful portrayal of Apollo Creed, Weathers contributed to one of the most memorable sagas in film history. Stallone’s recent reflection on their audition highlights the deep respect and admiration he had for Weathers, both as an actor and as a person. From the early days of their partnership to their final moments on-screen together, Weathers’ impact on Rocky remains undeniable. His talent, charisma, and presence were integral to the success of the series, and his legacy will continue to inspire generations of fans and filmmakers alike.