Wyatt’s Surprising Reaction to Baby Finnley’s Arrival: Was She Hoping for a Brother?

In a touching and highly publicized moment, Jason and Kylie Kelce welcomed their fourth child, Finnley “Finn” Anne Kelce, into the world on March 30, 2025. As one of the most talked-about families in the NFL community, the Kelces have embraced the joys and challenges of raising a growing family, often sharing their experiences with their followers. This article dives into the reactions of their three older daughters upon learning that their family would soon be expanding once again, shedding light on their emotional responses, as well as offering insights into how they are adjusting to life with their new baby sister.

Family Context and the Big Announcement
Jason Kelce, a retired NFL center for the Philadelphia Eagles and co-host of the podcast New Heights with his brother Travis Kelce, has become a beloved figure not just in football but in family circles. He and his wife, Kylie McDevitt Kelce, a former soccer player and now an active social media presence, have made their family life a key part of their public personas. Together, they have raised three daughters: Wyatt Elizabeth Kelce, born October 2, 2019; Elliotte Ray Kelce, born March 4, 2021; and Bennett Llewellyn Kelce, born February 23, 2023. Their family’s latest addition, Finnley, was announced on November 22, 2024, much to the delight of their fans and family members alike.

The announcement, made via an Instagram post by Kylie, showed the three older girls in adorable matching “big sister” sweaters, a moment that quickly became a talking point in the media. The photo, which captured the children’s reactions, offered a glimpse into the emotional landscape of the Kelce family as they prepared for the arrival of their new sibling. As of the announcement, the ages of the girls were 5 years (Wyatt), 3 years (Elliotte), and 1 year and 9 months (Bennett), which provided important context for understanding their varying responses to the news.

Reactions to the Announcement
The emotional reactions of the older Kelce girls, as revealed by Kylie’s social media posts and her podcast comments, were varied and sincere, reflecting their personalities and developmental stages. This candid snapshot of family life gives insight into how children at different ages process big changes in their lives, especially when it involves a new sibling.

Wyatt Kelce: At 5 years old, Wyatt, the oldest of the three, displayed an expression of disbelief in the announcement photo. While her face didn’t entirely reflect excitement, it seemed more like a moment of confusion or hesitation. According to Kylie, Wyatt’s reaction might have been shaped by a desire for a different outcome, such as hoping for a baby brother instead of a sister. This type of response is typical of a child who is old enough to understand the family dynamic but not yet fully able to grasp the impact of a new sibling, which can be both exciting and a bit unsettling. Media reports described Wyatt as a child who is sometimes emotional and prone to feelings of both happiness and sadness, which aligns with her more reserved reaction to the news.

Bennett Kelce: The youngest of the older girls, Bennett, at just 1 year and 9 months, had a notably strong reaction to the announcement. Captured sobbing in the photo, Bennett’s emotional response was both surprising and deeply relatable. Children of her age often feel the emotional intensity of changes in their family environment, even if they don’t fully understand what those changes mean. In a subsequent podcast episode of Not Gonna Lie, Kylie humorously noted that Bennett felt “deeply and personally victimized” by the news of another sibling, highlighting the strong emotional connection that very young children have to their immediate family structure. For Bennett, the introduction of a new sibling was an unexpected disruption to her world, leading to the emotional outpouring that many parents of young children can relate to during big family shifts.

Elliotte Kelce: In contrast to her older and younger sisters, Elliotte, at 3 years old, appeared to be the most accepting of the new arrival. In the announcement photo, Elliotte could be seen smiling brightly, a clear indication of her readiness to embrace her new role as a big sister once again. Kylie’s social media caption humorously noted that at least “Ellie, mom, and dad are on the same page!” suggesting that Elliotte’s reaction was one of enthusiasm and support for the family’s decision to welcome another child. Elliotte’s response could be attributed to her easygoing nature, often described as having “second child” energy—characteristics that typically include adaptability and a more relaxed attitude towards changes in family dynamics.