The NFL Doesn’t Need a ‘Saint’: How Harrison Butker Became the League’s Problem

Harrison Butker was once known simply as the Kansas City Chiefs’ reliable leg—a kicker who thrived under pressure and delivered in critical Super Bowl moments. But in 2024, he became a lightning rod for controversy, not for a missed field goal, but for a speech.

Invited to speak at Benedictine College’s commencement, Butker used the platform to promote traditional Catholic values, including controversial remarks about gender roles and criticisms of political leaders. What followed was a firestorm of media backlash and public division.

Supporters saw his words as an expression of free speech and religious conviction. Critics, however, slammed the address as tone-deaf and exclusionary—especially inappropriate for a diverse graduating class. Butker’s name quickly trended online, but not for reasons the NFL welcomes.

The league, distancing itself, issued a brief statement affirming that Butker’s opinions were his own. But the damage to his image—particularly outside of conservative circles—was already done. Some fans began calling for his release. Others feared that his personal views had begun to eclipse his professional identity.

In a league where image and unity are paramount, Butker’s stance placed him in direct conflict with the NFL’s evolving cultural tone. The incident reignited debates over whether athletes should mix faith and politics with football—and whether the NFL can afford to have its players alienate large swaths of its audience.

For Butker, the question now isn’t about accuracy on the field—it’s whether the league still sees value in a kicker who’s making headlines for all the wrong reasons.