Why A.J. Brown Chose John Legend and ‘All of Me’ for His Unforgettable Proposal
OPINION: This article may contain commentary which reflects the author's opinion.
When A.J. Brown of the Philadelphia Eagles proposed to longtime girlfriend Kelsey Riley, he didn’t just get down on one knee — he orchestrated a moment that felt straight out of a movie. The star wide receiver planned the entire proposal with precision, and at the center of it all was one stunning detail: Grammy-winner John Legend performing “All of Me” live on piano.
But why that song? And why that artist?
The answer lies in the emotional power of both.
“All of Me” isn’t just a love song — it’s a heartfelt pledge of unconditional devotion. With lyrics like “Love your curves and all your edges, all your perfect imperfections,” the track has become a global anthem for real, enduring love. Sources close to Brown say the song holds personal meaning for the couple, especially in how it celebrates deep, imperfect-but-beautiful relationships — a reflection of the journey Brown and Riley have shared.
As for why John Legend himself was there, the reason is just as romantic. Brown didn’t want just any performance — he wanted authenticity. He knew that only the man who wrote and originally sang the song could bring the emotion and intimacy it deserved. Inviting Legend wasn’t just about status; it was about sincerity. Legend’s smooth vocals and raw delivery added emotional weight to the proposal that no one else could replicate.
The proposal took place at the Four Seasons Hotel in Philadelphia, surrounded by candles, white roses, and close friends. Riley was so caught up in the moment that she didn’t even realize it was Legend playing live until Brown whispered it to her.
Legend later shared his congratulations and gratitude for being part of the special moment, calling it one of the most touching private performances he’s done.
Brown’s choice of song and artist wasn’t just about making a splash — it was about creating a memory that felt true, timeless, and deeply personal. And in doing so, he showed that even NFL stars can have a soft, poetic side when it comes to love.
