What Did Edelman Do to Make Vinatieri and Mankins Step Aside at The Hall
OPINION: This article may contain commentary which reflects the author's opinion.
In a surprising but fan-fueled decision, Julian Edelman has officially been voted into the New England Patriots Hall of Fame, beating out two franchise legends—kicker Adam Vinatieri and offensive lineman Logan Mankins. So what gave Edelman the edge in this heavyweight battle of Patriots greats?
It wasn’t just about stats. It was about heart, postseason magic, and a bond with fans forged through unforgettable moments.
Edelman’s career arc is one of the most unlikely in NFL history. A college quarterback turned seventh-round pick in 2009, Edelman reinvented himself as a wide receiver. Over 12 seasons with the Patriots, he amassed 620 receptions, 6,822 receiving yards, and 36 touchdowns—placing him second all-time in team history for catches, behind only Wes Welker.
But the regular season wasn’t where Edelman built his Hall of Fame case—it was the playoffs. He ranks second in NFL history for postseason receptions (118), trailing only Jerry Rice. From the game-winning touchdown in Super Bowl XLIX to the miracle fingertip catch in Super Bowl LI, Edelman always delivered when it mattered most. His MVP performance in Super Bowl LIII sealed his legacy.
Adam Vinatieri, though known as the most clutch kicker in NFL history, spent a significant portion of his career with the Indianapolis Colts. That likely impacted fan perception, as this vote was for the Patriots Hall of Fame—not the league’s. Logan Mankins, a six-time Pro Bowler, was a consistent protector on the offensive line, but his role rarely offered the kind of highlight moments fans latch onto.
Edelman, by contrast, became a symbol of the Patriots dynasty—gritty, underestimated, and always ready when the lights were brightest. His underdog story resonated deeply with the New England fan base.
In the end, fans didn’t just vote for stats—they voted for memories. For the guy who made them leap off the couch in February. For the catch. The moments. The edge-of-your-seat excitement.
And that’s how Julian Edelman—scrappy No. 11—earned his red jacket, making two legends step aside as Patriots history welcomed one of its most beloved warriors.
